Introduction
Most companies don't buy their insurance programme all at once. They build it up over the years: one policy when the warehouse opens, another when a customer requires it, another after a scare. And every year, when renewal comes round, they renew them almost without looking.
The problem is that the company changes faster than its policies. Turnover grows, machinery is bought, more people are hired, new markets open up. If insurance doesn't keep up with that change, coverage gaps appear that are only discovered when a claim happens.
This guide helps you review your insurance programme in five steps, with the key questions for each policy and a final checklist. You don't need to be an insurance expert: just have your policies to hand and know your company well.
When to review your insurance
Ideally, carry out a full review once a year, 60 to 90 days before the main renewal. That leaves time to analyse, ask the market for alternatives and negotiate. It's also worth reviewing your insurance whenever any of these changes happen:
- You open, expand or move premises, or make a significant investment in machinery or stock.
- You launch a new product or service, or start selling in other countries.
- Your workforce grows or your collective agreement changes.
- You sign a contract with a customer or supplier that requires specific insurance.
- You buy another company, a new shareholder comes in or you set up a subsidiary.
- You suffer a major claim or an insurer rejects a claim.
- You become critically dependent on IT systems or customer data.
Step 1. Take stock of your policies
The first step is knowing what you have. Gather all policies in force, including those taken out with the bank when applying for a loan, the vehicle policies and those managed by another department. For each one, note down:
| Item | Where to find it |
|---|---|
| Insurer and policy number | Particular conditions |
| Renewal date | Particular conditions |
| Assets or activity insured | Particular conditions |
| Sums insured | Particular conditions |
| Limits and sub-limits | Particular and special conditions |
| Deductibles | Particular conditions |
| Relevant exclusions | General and special conditions |
| Total annual premium | Policy premium receipt |
With this inventory you'll see at a glance how many policies you have, with how many insurers, when they renew and how much you pay in total. It's common to discover duplicate policies, others that no longer make sense and renewal dates scattered throughout the year.
Step 2. Map your company's risks
Before looking at the policies, think about the company. What could cause it a major loss? A simple way to organise it is by category:
- Assets: buildings, machinery, stock, IT equipment. How much would it cost to replace them today?
- Operations: how many days could the company be at a standstill without losing customers? Does it depend on a key supplier or facility?
- Third parties: what damage could your activity or products cause to customers, visitors or the environment?
- Professional services: do you advise, design or calculate for your clients? A mistake could cause them a financial loss.
- People: what does your collective agreement require? What benefits do you want to offer to attract and retain talent?
- Management: do you have external shareholders, bank financing or investors? Are your directors protected?
- Digital: what would happen if tomorrow you couldn't access your systems or customer data were leaked?
- Transport and international: do you move goods? Do you sell, buy or have employees in other countries?
The aim is to compare this map with the inventory from step 1. Every major risk should have a policy covering it, with a proportionate limit.
Step 3. Review each policy with the key questions
These are the most common policies for a small or mid-sized company, the questions worth asking and the most frequent warning signs. Click on each one to see them.
Property damage
Key questions
Do the sums insured reflect the current cost of rebuilding and replacing? Is cover on a replacement-value or actual-value basis? Is it an all-risks or a named-perils policy?
Warning signs
Sums insured not updated for years. Recent investments not reported. Low sub-limits for stock or electronic equipment.
Business interruption
Key questions
Does the indemnity period cover the real time it would take to recover? Does it include a standstill caused by a loss at a key supplier or customer?
Warning signs
This cover doesn't exist. An indemnity period of three or six months when rebuilding would take a year.
General and product liability
Key questions
Is the limit enough for the worst realistic scenario? Does it cover products sold abroad? Does it include accidental pollution?
Warning signs
Limits set years ago. Undeclared exports. Customer contracts requiring higher limits.
Professional liability
Key questions
Does it cover all the services you provide today? What retroactive period does it have?
Warning signs
New activities not included in the risk description. Limited retroactive cover after changing insurer.
D&O
Key questions
Does it cover all directors and officers, including former ones? Does it include defence in administrative proceedings? Does it extend to subsidiaries?
Warning signs
This policy doesn't exist. An insufficient limit after new shareholders or financing came in. No run-off cover in a sale.
Cyber Risk
Key questions
Does it cover incident response, business interruption and third-party claims? What security measures does the insurer require?
Warning signs
This policy doesn't exist. Required measures (such as two-factor authentication or backups) that the company doesn't meet.
Fleet and vehicles
Key questions
Are all vehicles included? Does the cover match the use and value of each one?
Warning signs
Vehicles no longer in use that are still being paid for. Individual policies that could be grouped into a fleet.
Cargo
Key questions
Does it cover all routes and means of transport? Who bears the risk under the agreed Incoterm?
Warning signs
Uninsured goods in transit. Per-shipment limits below the value of actual shipments.
Employee benefits insurance
Key questions
Do you have the insurance your collective agreement requires (accident, life)? Do you offer health insurance as a benefit?
Warning signs
Agreement amounts out of date after a pay review or a change of agreement. New employees not included.
Trade credit
Key questions
Are your main customers covered? How much of your turnover depends on a few customers?
Warning signs
Sales concentrated in a few customers with no protection against non-payment.
Step 4. Look for gaps and duplication
The most serious problems usually aren't in what each policy says, but in what falls between them. Pay particular attention to these points:
- Underinsurance. If the sum insured is below the real value, the insurer will apply the average clause and pay only part of the loss, even on a small claim.
- Sub-limits. A policy with a high overall limit can have very low sub-limits for specific covers, such as machinery breakdown or pollution.
- Exclusions. Check that no exclusion leaves out a core risk of your business.
- Territorial scope. If you sell, buy or work outside Spain, confirm that your policies cover those countries.
- Changes of insurer. With claims-made liability policies, a poorly managed change can leave earlier events uncovered.
- Third-party contracts. Check which insurance your customers, landlords and lenders require, and whether your policies meet those requirements.
- Group companies. Check that all companies, including new ones, are named as insureds.
- Duplication. Two policies covering the same risk don't pay you twice. They only double the cost.
Step 5. Prepare the renewal
With the review done, it's time to improve the programme. These are the steps that make the difference at renewal:
- Prepare good information. Insurers offer better terms when they understand the risk well. An up-to-date description of the business, its prevention measures and its claims history is the best negotiating tool.
- Align renewal dates. Grouping renewals into one or two dates a year makes management and negotiation easier.
- Compare cover, not just prices. A lower premium with more exclusions or higher deductibles can turn out far more expensive.
- Decide which risk you keep. Raising a deductible can lower the premium, but only if the company can absorb that amount without difficulty.
- Document changes. Any significant change during the year must be reported to the insurer. If an increase in risk isn't declared, the claim payment may be reduced.
Final checklist
Before renewing, check that you can answer yes to these ten questions:
How Gregal helps
Reviewing an insurance programme takes time and requires a good knowledge of policies. At Gregal we do it for you: we analyse your policies, identify coverage gaps and duplication, and propose a 360° insurance programme tailored to your company. We explain every decision clearly and negotiate the best terms with insurers. And if you're preparing a corporate transaction, we make sure your insurance is ready for it.
Would you rather we reviewed it for you?
We analyse your policies, find gaps and duplication and propose a programme tailored to you.