1. Home
  2. Insights
  3. D&O for growing companies
Article · Business insurance · D&O

Your company is growing. Are your directors protected?

6-minute readGregal

Growth is good news. More customers, more employees, new investors, perhaps the first acquisition or the first subsidiary abroad. But each of those steps has a consequence few companies analyse in time: the personal exposure of the people making the decisions increases.

At Gregal we see it often. Mid-market companies that have professionalised their management but still protect their directors as they did when they were much smaller, or don't protect them at all. In this article we explain why the consolidation phase changes the risk and what the D&O policy that covers it should look like.

Directors' liability doesn't depend on company size

From the day they accept the role, directors are liable with their own assets for any damage caused by breaching their duties. Spain's Companies Act requires them to act with the diligence of a prudent businessperson and with loyalty to the company. They are not expected to always be right, but to decide on an informed basis and without conflicts of interest.

If they don't, they can face claims from the company itself, its shareholders, its creditors or third parties. And there are other routes that are a particular concern for mid-sized companies:

  • Company debts: if the company falls into grounds for dissolution due to losses and the board does not act in time, directors can be jointly liable for subsequent debts.
  • Tax authorities: the Spanish Tax Agency can shift liability for certain tax debts of the company onto its directors.
  • Insolvency proceedings: if the insolvency is classified as culpable, they can be ordered to cover the company's shortfall with their own assets.
  • Social Security and employment: in certain cases, they can also be liable for employment debts and social security contributions.

What changes as the company consolidates

In a startup, the risk is concentrated in the founders and their first investors. In a company in its consolidation phase, the risk spreads and grows in size. These are the situations we see most often:

  • 1. More scrutiny. Size brings tax and labour inspections and, in some sectors, the attention of the competition authority or specific regulators. Directors are the natural target of enforcement proceedings, and defending them costs money from the very first request.
  • 2. More complex employment relations. Furlough schemes, collective redundancies, collective disputes or departures of senior executives. All are common at this stage and all can end in a claim against whoever made the decision.
  • 3. Corporate transactions. Acquisitions, mergers, spin-offs or a fund coming into the capital. If a deal doesn't go as expected, shareholders can question how it was decided, what information was taken into account and whether there were conflicts of interest.
  • 4. More demanding new shareholders. A private equity fund or a family office doesn't behave like a founding shareholder: it has legal teams, demands information and is prepared to claim if it believes management has harmed its investment.
  • 5. Larger liabilities. The larger the company, the larger its debts. If financial difficulties arrive, the amount of any insolvency-related liability for directors can be very high.

What D&O insurance covers

D&O protects the personal assets of directors and officers against claims arising from their management. In practice, it covers three things:

  • Defence costs: lawyers, court representatives, experts and court costs, which the insurer advances without waiting for the proceedings to end. It is the most used cover, because even an unfounded claim can cost a lot of money.
  • Damages: the amounts the director must pay under a judgment or a settlement.
  • Investigations and administrative proceedings: the costs of dealing with an inspection or enforcement proceedings, if the policy expressly includes them.

Policies are usually organised in three parts: direct protection for the director when the company cannot indemnify them (Side A), reimbursement to the company when it does (Side B) and, in some cases, cover for the company itself (Side C).

Like any insurance, it has exclusions. The most common are wilful or fraudulent acts, unlawful personal gain, claims known before inception and fines and penalties that the law does not allow to be insured.

What D&O should look like for a growing company

There's no standard policy. But at this stage there are six aspects that are always worth reviewing:

  • An adequate limit. As a reference, between 3 and 10 million euros, depending on size, sector, leverage and international presence. It's important to remember that the limit is shared between all insureds and all claims in the year.
  • Administrative proceedings. Express cover for defence costs before the tax authorities, the labour inspectorate, the competition authority or other regulators.
  • Officers, not just board members. The policy should also protect the CFO, the HR director or the sales director, even if they're not on the board, and anyone acting as a de facto director.
  • Former directors. Someone who leaves the role can face claims years later for decisions made during their term. An appropriate retroactive date prevents them from being left unprotected.
  • Subsidiaries. If the group grows with new companies, in Spain or abroad, cover should automatically extend to their directors.
  • M&A deals. If the company is sold or a new controlling shareholder comes in, outgoing directors need cover that keeps responding for several years (run-off). It should be negotiated before signing, not after. More in M&A insurance.

Three mistakes we see often

  • Buying it too late. D&O must be in force before difficulties appear. When a company is already in a delicate financial situation, buying or renewing it on good terms is very difficult.
  • Cancelling it to save money. It's one of the first budget lines to be cut in a bad year, just when it's needed most.
  • Renewing it out of inertia. A policy taken out five years ago, with the same limit and the same terms, will hardly reflect today's company: more employees, more shareholders, more companies and more deals.

How Gregal helps

We analyse the risk profile of your company and its directors, review your current policy if you have one and negotiate with insurers a D&O policy that fits your stage: limits, covers and exclusions clearly explained before signing. And because we support companies both day to day and in their corporate transactions, we make sure your D&O is coordinated with the rest of your insurance programme and ready for your next deal.

Is your D&O keeping up with your company?

We review your current policy and tell you clearly what we would improve and what we wouldn't.